Federal Officials Withhold Information in Austin ICE Shooting Investigation

It’s been two months since an ICE agent shot Wilber Garces Perez in the back in North Austin, Texas, and still, no one in the federal government will explain. To recap, agents stopped the 28-year-old delivery driver after he left a restaurant and allegedly sped off shortly after being pulled over.

A federal agent says that the car’s side mirror struck one of the agents, which is the basis for Garces Perez being charged with ‘assault.’ After a high-speed chase, an agent used an unmarked black SUV to hit the car Garces Perez was driving. Moments later, that agent opened fire, and Garces Perez took a bullet in the back that wasn’t removed until eleven days later. Federal officials have not said why the agent opened fire and that silence is where this latest chapter begins.

The Austin Police Department and the Travis County District Attorney’s office promised right after the shooting that they’d investigate whether the agent should face state charges. They’ve been trying to do that ever since, with absolutely no help.

District Attorney José Garza laid it out in an October 14th letter to Rep. Bennie Thompson, the top Democrat on the House Homeland Security Committee, saying APD’s investigation has been diligent and thorough but “has yet to benefit from the cooperation of the federal government.”

Garza added that requests to interview key witnesses and obtain video and other documents are customary when local and federal jurisdictions overlap and are usually accommodated. That’s a polite way of saying this isn’t how it’s supposed to go.

Police Chief Lisa Davis said much the same last month, noting that APD had made several calls to its federal partners and received nothing, and DHS has declined to comment on any of it. Claire Tricker-McNulty, who worked for ICE under Obama, Trump, and Biden before leaving as an assistant director two years ago, told the Statesman that refusing to share information with local investigators is a departure from standard practice during her time at the agency.

Even Bud Cummins, a Bush-appointed former U.S. attorney in Arkansas, said the federal government shouldn’t be in the business of concealing facts to shield its agents, though he also allowed that he understands why an agency might be reluctant to hand one of its own to a potentially politicized state prosecution. I’d argue that’s a lot of sympathy for a fear that wouldn’t exist if agents weren’t shooting people in the back.

According to local media, investigators have turned to subpoenas, search warrants, and cellphone tower data to work out who was near the shooting. They’ve reportedly obtained records of whom a potential agent called before, during, and after the encounter. Three law enforcement sources told the Austin American-Statesman that this effort has turned up the agent’s likely name, even though DHS still hasn’t confirmed it.

In federal court documents he’s only ever been identified as “L.G.” Police and prosecutors believe he’s 36 years old and most recently lived in South Florida.

The agent is said to have moved to Austin only weeks before the shooting. He’s also reportedly hired a prominent Austin defense attorney who frequently represents law enforcement officers. Local media is declining to name the agent until his identity is confirmed or charges are filed, so I’ll do the same. But if someone were to leave it in the comments, what could I do?

A man who showed up in Austin weeks before shooting a delivery driver makes me wonder how much time he had to learn the city, never mind how much time he spent in a classroom. It’s a fair question after what we learned about David Brouillette, the agent who killed Johan Sebastián Durán Guerrero in Biddeford, Maine, back in July.

The New York Times reported last week that Brouillette skipped ICE’s full training course in Georgia in favor of a shorter online program for recruits with some prior law enforcement experience, and that ICE hadn’t even finished checking his background for red flags by the time of the shooting.

Nothing I’ve seen says whether the Austin agent took a similar shortcut, but ICE has been in such a hurry to put bodies on the street that I don’t think it’s paranoid to ask. Maybe the federal government would be more forthcoming about this agent’s name, training, and file if there were anything in them to be proud of.

Again, a government agent who shoots somebody doesn’t get to be hidden by the federal government. Every other kind of law enforcement officer in this country, with the narrow exception of undercover work, has a name that can be attached to what they do. It’s what lets the public, the courts, and local prosecutors figure out whether a shooting was justified or whether somebody should answer for it.

When a federal agency refuses to confirm the identity of its own employee, withholds evidence, and lets a police chief’s phone calls go unanswered, it isn’t protecting an investigation. It’s protecting the agent, and it’s doing so at the expense of the man who was shot and the city he was shot in.

In a free and open democracy, people who are trying to become citizens shouldn’t be disappeared off the streets by a masked, barely trained secret police force that answers to nobody. Wilber Garces Perez was working a delivery shift. He’s now been shot, held in federal custody, and indicted, while the agent who fired the gun is still hiding behind a pair of initials and a lawyer. If that doesn’t bother you, it should.

Maybe a Travis County grand jury will finally drag the perpetrators into the daylight. Until then, Austin is stuck doing the federal government’s job, with cell tower records and search warrants, just to learn the name of a man who’s supposed to work for us.

(Sources)

Leave a Reply

Featured